Evey is bragging about this guy she had sex with a few nights before and his huge cock. She tells the girls he is supposed to be coming to the fancy dress party dressed as the killer from the movie Scream. The girls spot the costume and call him over. They try pulling up his tunic and he tries to fight them off but Evey covers his mouth and tells him not to speak. When they pull his tunic up they are very disappointed at the small size of his penis, but Evey starts stroking it, telling them it gets much bigger. Kaicee puts it in her mouth and sucks it but when young stunner Lucie grabs hold of his cock and starts pumping it, the guy can't hold back any longer and cums all over his stomach. Evey lifts up his mask to kiss him, but is horrified to find she has never seen this guy before in her life!